Charming is the prefect color for me! I love the way it goes on, it last long, just not the tingle. I have a lot of allergies, to everything so j usually don't even try anything wit tingle in it. Having lupus my skin is EXTREMELY sensitive so the tingle usually burns me. This tingle does not however, it's just a light tingle for the first few minutes. Luckily I'm not allergic either. I would def recommend to others.