I have this in the nude/light color, and I really like the way it goes on. I have a tube type one from another brand that separates if I don't use it every day; meaning I end up massaging the tube to mix it back together. This stuff, however, is great! No separating, no odd liquid quality, just tap it on and you're set! I have worn it both with and without shadow, and I like it both ways. Under eye shadow, it really locks the color on. On it's own, it evens out the tone of my eye lids, leaving a natural look. I like the portability of it for travel as well. I don't have to worry about it bursting in my makeup bag!